Quantum Advisory says proposals to delay workplace pension reforms until 2031 reflect growing financial pressures on employers, but warns younger workers could pay the price.
Mounting employment costs facing UK businesses have brought plans to extend workplace pensions to younger workers into question, with a leading pensions expert warning that employers’ financial pressures must be balanced against the long-term retirement prospects of employees.
Stuart Price, Partner and Actuary at independent pensions consultancy Quantum Advisory, says recent increases in employer National Insurance costs and the National Minimum Wage have created significant challenges for businesses, particularly SMEs.
His comments follow the publication of the Government-commissioned Milburn Review, which recommends delaying planned reforms to workplace pension automatic enrolment for employees under 25 until at least 2031.
The reforms, provided for under legislation passed in 2023 but not yet implemented, would reduce the minimum age for automatic enrolment from 22 to 18 and remove the lower earnings limit for pension contributions.
The review (published on November 17) recommends postponing these changes for younger workers to help businesses manage employment costs and encourage the recruitment of young people.
Stuart said: “I can understand the concern around reducing the minimum age to 18 and the additional cost this would place on employers.
“Many employers are already struggling with the recent changes to National Insurance, including the reduction in the secondary threshold, alongside increases in the National Minimum Wage.
“With these concerns and the goals of the review in mind, I can see merit in Milburn’s recommendations to help the younger generation getting gainful employment and contributing to the economy at a younger age.”
The Milburn Review, led by former Cabinet minister Alan Milburn, examines the growing number of young people not in education, employment or training and proposes a 10-year programme of reforms covering employment, education, health and welfare.
However, Stuart warned that while delaying additional pension costs may provide relief for employers, it could also have unintended consequences for younger workers.
He said: “The continued delayed implementation of the Pensions (Extension of Automatic Enrolment) Act 2023 could have an impact on younger employees entering the workforce and their ability to save for retirement as soon as they start their working lives, potentially promoting the wrong message to them that saving for their retirement is not important.
“Since 2012 auto-enrolment has been one of the success stories within the pension industry, driving a surge in workplace pension participation.
“Those who do not currently fall into scope for eligibility are not seeing the benefits of this and risk being left behind in forming a solid foundation of savings for their future.”
Stuart believes the challenge for policymakers is to balance the immediate cost pressures facing employers with the need to ensure workers build sufficient retirement savings.
He also warned that existing minimum pension contribution levels remain too low to deliver comfortable retirement incomes for many employees.
“Reform for auto-enrolment needs to progress, rather than be delayed. For all employees, even those who are already benefitting from auto-enrolment, more still needs to be done.
“The combined minimum total contribution is low and will not provide savers with enough for a comfortable retirement.
“A gradual increase in contribution levels, up to at least 12% instead of the current 8%, could make a significant difference to people’s pension savings and future retirement experiences.”
The debate is expected to intensify ahead of the revived Pensions Commission’s final report in February 2027, which will examine pension adequacy and the risks of undersaving.
Stuart added: “As the Commission is aware of both the barriers to sustainable retirement outcomes and the additional cost burdens for employers and SMEs, it will be interesting to see whether its recommended steps align with Milburn’s proposals.”