Written by Kunal Sawnhey
Under pressure, Chancellor Sunak has finally announced a windfall tax on oil and gas companies, an idea that Labour and the Liberal Democrats have advocated. Sunak’s announcement of a £15billion package to support households struggling with the cost of living crisis will be one-third (£5billion) funded by the one-off levy imposed on the energy companies.
The energy companies were long on the radar as the surge in demand and the prevailing geopolitical situations had led to an astronomical rise in global commodity prices, which resulted in extraordinary profits for the oil and gas sector. As the profits were solely due to circumstances and not because of companies going for risk-taking or innovation, there was demand from different corners to tax that bonanza.
Now, the energy firms will have to pay an additional 25 per cent tax for the next 12 months, and the scale of excess profits made by electricity generators is also being looked upon seriously. However, Sunak has also made it clear that it is a “temporary targeted energy profits levy”. He has also assured that tax would be withdrawn when energy prices return to normal levels.
There was fear being raised that investment may take a hit if the energy companies are taxed, so considering that Sunak also announced a plan of a new investment allowance, according to which for every pound a company invests, they will get back 90 per cent in tax relief, this paves the way for more investment to pay less taxes.
Will the windfall tax solve the misery of the UK households?
For the last sometimes, calls to do more to help households hit by record-high inflation have increased, and that was the reason that the government took a U-turn on the windfall tax on the energy companies. Households across the country are reeling under a severe cost of living crisis as the prices of food, fuel, and energy have all surged to a record high, and the overall inflation reached a 40-year peak of 9 per cent.
There are voices coming out that the measures announced are “too little, too late”. Domestic energy bills are expected to jump more than 40 per cent later this year, and this meagre help may not be able to support the households if there is no respite in the inflationary situation. On the other hand, there are talks that this measure could result in a rise in inflation in the country. One of the government’s most loyal ministers Jacob Rees-Mogg has even warned that all taxation has an economic consequence, and this windfall tax would have too. Also, it could affect the money paid out to pensioners by some pension funds that are deep into energy investment in companies going to be taxed.
How are the energy companies going to be impacted?
Oil and gas companies, especially those operating in the North Sea, are supposed to pay a higher corporation tax of 30 per cent compared to 19 per cent paid by other corporates. They also have to pay an additional 10 per cent supplementary tax on their profits. However, there is a catch, they get the advantage of things like decommissioning North Sea oil platforms, which reduces the amount of tax they pay, and in actual terms, the tax paid is comparatively very low to the profits they make.
Still, many companies have been raising voices against any such imposition of tax. Recently, 31 organisations in the UK’s offshore energy supply chain have written an open letter against any such imposition of the tax, saying that it may not sustainably help consumers.
As there are talks of widening the tax to include electricity generators, the chief executive of the energy supplier SSE, Alistair Phillips-Davies, had even said that the windfall tax could damage Britain’s progress in building up domestic sources of electricity and gas. If the scope is widened, it could also include smaller generators that benefited from an early subsidy scheme and have amassed handsome profits from high wholesale power prices.
Final thoughts
The government’s package part-funded by the windfall tax includes a £650 one-off payment for eight million low-income households. Also, they would receive an extra £200 discount on their fuel bills in October, apart from the already promised £200 during the Spring statement, without the need to pay it back. All these measures are surely going to provide some relief to the UK households, and there could be some respite for the manufacturing and leisure sectors. However, in the long run, it could also drive up the domestic costs of energy with reduced investment in renewables.