Written by Chizubel Egwudo, founder and CEO of specialist risk consultancy, The Risk of You
Cryptocurrencies have forever changed the way many people use money to transact.
Historically, we have witnessed the evolution of transaction methods first hand, from trade by barter and cowrie shells, to paper money, and now, cryptocurrency [also known as digital money].
In today’s increasingly digital world, digital money makes sense as a new payment technology, however it presents some significant issues that must be solved in order for it to function well.
At the time of writing this article [28/11/2023], Bitcoin transactions per day were recorded on YCharts as 926.66M, at a staggering price of £29,377.76 according to CoinDesk.
What is driving cryptocurrency market momentum?
Cryptocurrencies, like Bitcoin, Etherium and the thousands of others available come with substantial risks which can be quite impactful, both positively and negatively, when they materialise.
The well-publicised FTX bankruptcy is a clear example of the level of risk in the industry. Rife with poor risk management practices or deliberate malpractice, and outright fraud, the losses to consumers and businesses alike has been staggering.
Despite this, some government authorities and central banks are jumping on the digital currency trend by issuing their own cryptocurrency such as the Central Bank Digital Currencies [CBDCs]. This is leaving some crypto enthusiasts feeling uncertain as to the government’s true intentions, since it has the power to enact legislative and regulatory controls.
As financial institutions explore this territory, it is more important than ever that they implement strategies that protect consumers, and that they are agile and aware of the many threats associated with digital currencies.
Volatility of digital asset markets
Cryptocurrencies and Non-fungible Tokens [NFTs], are characterised by a high degree of volatility and are difficult to liquidate, exposing banks to considerable market and liquidity risks.
Unbacked crypto assets, such as Bitcoin and Ether, typically display considerable price volatility, with periods of strong price appreciation often followed by equally rapid price falls, which can create unfathomable gains or losses.
Digital assets also rely heavily on relatively new technology and involve unregulated players in the ecosystem, which may result in heightened and more pronounced operational and legal risks than those typically associated with traditional banking products and business models.
Lack of regulation
Regulatory authorities around the world have yet to develop and establish a robust framework for institutions operating in the digital asset ecosystem, further elevating the threat exposures and problems.
According to Bank of England’s outgoing deputy governor, Sir Jon Cunliffe, for financial stability, regulators need to “get on with the job” of bringing the use of crypto technologies within the “regulatory perimeter,”.
The question now is, do regulators really know how to get this job done? Should they collaborate with independent crypto companies to create a level playing field?
Fraud and cybersecurity concerns
Cryptocurrencies are used by criminals to perpetrate scams, fraud and money laundering.
While it is difficult to quantify the value of losses from cryptocurrency scams in comparison with government issued currency, in the very short space of time since cryptocurrency came to market, significant damage has been done to consumers who invest in digital assets.
In July 2022, Santander warned of an 87% surge in crypto scams compared with the previous year.
Criminals have posed as legitimate organisations offering astronomical returns on investment through cryptocurrency multi-level marketing schemes [also known as ‘pyramid schemes’].
Some of these criminals have fabricated endorsements with footballers, film stars, politicians and celebrities, including the likes of Christiano Ronaldo and Tony Blair, and have sponsored reputable organisations and events to appear legitimate before suddenly disappearing. People fell for these promotions and bought into these cryptos and lost their life savings.
Furthermore, 2022 was the biggest year ever for crypto hacking, with £2.9 billion stolen from cryptocurrency businesses according to Chainalysis. Revolut, Lloyds Bank and HSBC are just some the banks whose customers have paid millions of pounds out to crypto currency scams.
Considering this, the financial services industry has been urged to develop robust controls for cryptocurrency transactions like those they have in place for traditional currencies, in order to protect the economy.
Conclusion
While cryptocurrencies and their underlying technologies clearly offer many advantages for financial services and markets, investing in digital currencies involves substantial risks, all of which needs to be evaluated.
By understanding the opportunities and threats, and knowing the appropriate responses to take, financial institutions can navigate the challenges inherent in cryptocurrency’s ever growing and highly volatile market.
Crucially, financial institutions should not merely pivot to cryptocurrencies to capitalise on the current boom. Instead, they must ask themselves if the approach is aligned with their brand purpose, what is the Risk to Customers, Risk to Firm and Risk to Market, and if their environment is tolerable to the appetite sought to satisfy.