FCA Targeted Support Consultation: Hymans Robertson Personal Wealth comments

Commenting on the Financial Conduct Authority’s (FCA) Targeted Support Consultation closing today, Julie Hammerton, Managing Partner, Hymans Robertson Personal Wealth, added:

“If individuals are receiving contrasting suggestions from different providers, this could lead to more consumer confusion, greater levels of disengagement and more distrust, acting as a significant barrier to adoption. Secondly, it would enable firms to get up and running faster in respect of creating their own suggestions while not stifling innovation. In tandem, this would remove some risk for firms looking to provide targeted support, potentially encouraging greater adoption. This approach would allow the government and FCA to observe the roll out of targeted support before opening the doors too widely. Without some guardrails at the outset, it could veer off course. If it is proceeding as hoped, and data access and AI applications have advanced significantly, there may be a more prudent course of action. Lastly, this approach will also provide a baseline of what good looks like between identifying and clarifying the ‘situation’ with the ‘purpose’ of that specific piece of targeted support.

“We also have concerns regarding the lack of centralisation on consumer segments. Trying to build segments that are not overly individualised, but not so broad as to be inappropriate, could be a challenge. The line between targeted support and simplified advice in this regard is not clear.

“By relying on ‘reasonable assumptions’, instead of collecting data and information from consumers, this could lead to individuals being in worse positions than if this information was collected. There is a danger that being purist about definitions could act as a barrier to individuals being put in a better position. The challenge in this is knowing what is ‘personalised’ versus ‘too individualised’ and where the boundary lies.

“A joined-up approach, with the Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS) is critical, as otherwise the risk of redress could stifle innovation, even when the innovation seeks to give people better support than they can currently access. Allowing firms to suggest specific investment products, or suggest alternatives, may make them more willing to take the risk, especially as the FCA has said it expects targeted support to be made available at no charge. Ensuring consumers understand the risks they are taking, and that any signposted products represent fair value will be key to avoiding harm.”

About Lisa Baker, Editor 3105 Articles
Lisa Baker is the Editor of Always Finance, and writes about Business, Finance Technology and Healthcare. Lisa is also the owner of Need to See IT Publishing.