As HMRC seeks to maximise tax revenue, it appears to have turned its attention to doctors’ expenses. We’ve seen so-called ‘nudge’ letters sent to doctors questioning whether they are genuinely entitled to refunds claimed on their tax returns.
These one-to-many letters have been used by HMRC for several years to target specific groups and encourage them to correct any errors and pay any tax owed. Thousands are sent out, and while they don’t necessarily indicate that a formal investigation is imminent, they should not be ignored.
Recent letters we’ve seen highlight doctors’ tax returns with “substantial employment expenses which do not appear to be in line with the nature of your employment and, as a result, the repayment has not been issued.” The letters warn that if there is no response within 30 days, HMRC will consider opening a formal compliance check.
What you can claim
Doctors often claim expenses for travel between hospitals, hotel and subsistence costs, and professional fees for activities such as training. However, there is a risk of mistakenly claiming for non-deductible items like everyday clothing or ineligible travel expenses.
Expenses can be claimed if they are wholly, exclusively, and necessarily incurred for employment purposes. But it’s important to consider: if those expenses are truly required for your job, why isn’t your employer reimbursing you? If your employer pays less than HMRC’s approved mileage rates, you can claim the difference from HMRC.
While insurance policies usually don’t cover responding to nudge letters because they don’t constitute a formal inquiry, our tax experts can provide advice and support to individuals or their accountants. We closely monitor HMRC’s use of nudge letters, which in the past have targeted partnership income, offshore income and gains, foreign tax credit relief, and crypto assets.
Our advice to anyone receiving a nudge letter is simple. Take it seriously. Review the letter’s content carefully. What specific area is HMRC questioning? Assess your tax position in that context. If there’s an issue, address it and seek professional advice. Even if you believe your tax affairs are correct, we strongly recommend responding to HMRC. For example, you could write back stating: “I have received your letter, reviewed my tax position, and believe my taxes are fully up to date with nothing to disclose.”
Three common ways to respond to nudge letters:
- Do nothing but this may mean you won’t receive your refund and could trigger a formal compliance check.
- Push back by pointing out that since the nudge letter isn’t a formal inquiry, HMRC should release the refund.
- Request a formal process stating you’re willing to answer HMRC’s questions but prefer to do so through a formal inquiry.
Expenses must be wholly, exclusively, and necessarily incurred for employment to be deductible.
Increasing tax focus
We expect HMRC’s focus on tax compliance to intensify as the government moves to recruit 5,000 new compliance officers over the next five years, around 10% of whom are already in place, though they will require training.
HMRC’s current approach appears to centre on three key areas:
- Nudge letters, which have proven to be a cost-effective revenue source
- Routine enquiries into sole traders, partnerships, and companies
- Targeted action on specific issues, such as tax avoidance schemes
As HMRC continues to expand its compliance activities, it’s more important than ever for taxpayers especially those receiving nudge letters to carefully review their tax affairs and seek professional advice where needed.