Fresh political uncertainty surrounding Prime Minister Keir Starmer could place renewed pressure on the pound and UK government bonds if speculation over Labour leadership tensions intensifies, according to investment analysts.
The warning comes after Labour MP Catherine West reportedly threatened to initiate a leadership challenge against Starmer unless a cabinet minister steps forward to contest his position following damaging local election results for Labour.
The developments have triggered growing debate within Westminster about Starmer’s authority and the potential for internal divisions to emerge inside the government less than a year after Labour returned to power.
Nigel Green, chief executive of deVere Group, said financial markets tend to react sharply when political instability threatens confidence in economic management.
“Financial markets can tolerate unpopular governments. They can tolerate weak poll numbers. What they struggle with is uncertainty over leadership, economic direction and fiscal discipline.
“Sterling and UK government bonds, or gilts, become vulnerable the moment investors sense control is slipping.”
Although reports suggest only a small number of MPs currently back the idea of a formal challenge, investors are closely monitoring the situation amid concerns that political disputes inside governing parties can escalate quickly once public criticism begins.
Markets have generally responded positively to Labour’s efforts under Starmer and Chancellor Rachel Reeves to project fiscal discipline and economic stability. Analysts say any perception that this approach could change may unsettle investors.
“The current leadership has spent considerable political capital convincing investors Britain has moved away from the instability and fiscal recklessness associated with previous crises,” explains the deVere chief executive.
“If investors begin to fear a leadership vacuum, ideological infighting or a shift toward looser spending policies, markets could react fast and aggressively.”
Currency markets are expected to be particularly sensitive to political developments, with traders watching closely for any signs that confidence in Britain’s economic direction is weakening.
“Sterling is highly sensitive to political credibility because the UK runs persistent deficits and depends heavily on international capital flows. Political instability can rapidly undermine confidence in British assets.”
Analysts believe the pound could weaken against traditional safe-haven currencies including the US dollar, Swiss franc and Japanese yen if uncertainty deepens in the coming weeks.
Attention has also focused on the potential impact on UK government bonds, with memories still fresh from the financial turmoil triggered by former Prime Minister Liz Truss and the controversial mini-budget of September 2022.
“Britain remains unusually vulnerable to political credibility shocks because investors remember exactly how quickly confidence evaporated during the Truss budget crisis,” says Nigel Green.
“Bond traders are now almost conditioned to react swiftly to any sign fiscal discipline could weaken.”
Several senior Labour figures, including Health Secretary Wes Streeting, Deputy Prime Minister Angela Rayner and Greater Manchester Mayor Andy Burnham, have already been discussed as possible future leadership contenders should pressure on Starmer continue to grow.
At the same time, some analysts believe a failed challenge could ultimately strengthen the Prime Minister’s position if it demonstrates continued support within the Parliamentary Labour Party.
“The political risk premium attached to UK assets has fallen significantly since Labour entered government,” notes Nigel Green.
But, he concludes, political stability is fragile.
“Once doubts emerge over leadership and economic continuity, markets do not wait politely for Westminster to resolve itself.”
Source: deVere Group