Is Buy-To-Let becoming a riskier investment? Why 40% of landlords now ask for a guarantor

For years, buy-to-let rentals were seen as one of Britain’s most reliable investments. But as rising costs, stricter regulations around renters’ rights and rental affordability pressures change the market, landlords are increasingly looking for additional financial protection before handing over the keys.

One of the clearest signs of this shift is the growing use of rent guarantors. 

Recent market analysis suggests that up to 40% of landlords now ask for a guarantor for new tenancies, a big increase from previous years and a reflection of the changing risk profile facing property investors.

With rent arrears across England and Wales averaging £12,708 and landlords facing greater scrutiny under new rental legislation, many are becoming more cautious about who they let their properties to.

Why are more landlords asking for guarantors?

At its core, the buy-to-let market has always involved balancing risk and reward.

While rental income can provide a steady return, landlords are still exposed to missed rent payments, void periods, maintenance costs, mortgage payments and legal expenses. In recent years, many of those risks have intensified.

Interest rates are also still significantly higher than they were just a few years ago, reducing profit margins for many landlords. At the same time, new legislative reforms have increased compliance obligations and made landlords more conscious of potential financial exposure if a tenancy goes wrong.

As a result, many landlords are looking for extra reassurance before approving a tenant.

A guarantor provides exactly that. If a tenant is unable to pay their rent, the guarantor becomes legally responsible for covering the debt, helping reduce the financial risk associated with the tenancy.

Tenants are struggling to afford higher rental costs

Many landlords and letting agents now want tenants to earn at least 2.5 times their annual rent. Based on average UK rents of around £1,438 per month, that means a prospective tenant would need to earn around £43,140 per year. However, average UK earnings currently sit at around £41,859.

While the gap may seem relatively small on paper, it means a growing number of otherwise responsible tenants are failing affordability checks despite being in full-time employment and having stable incomes.

This has created a situation where guarantors are increasingly being used to bridge affordability gaps rather than simply protect against high-risk tenants.

According to Generation Rent, 42% of renters who moved home within the previous year were asked to provide a guarantor, up from just 26% five years earlier.

Which tenants are finding it harder to secure a rental property?

The stereotype of a guarantor being something only students need is becoming increasingly outdated.

Young professionals aged between 20 and 30 remain among the groups most likely to require a guarantor, being roughly twice as likely to be asked for one compared with renters over the age of 30.

However, this is also spreading into demographics that traditionally would not have expected to need one.

Middle-income earners are increasingly being caught by affordability rules. Research shows that the proportion of tenants earning between £25,000 and £49,999 who are asked to provide a guarantor has increased by more than 50% since 2020.

Self-employed workers, freelancers, contractors, those with limited UK credit history, international tenants and individuals relocating for work can also face additional scrutiny from landlords and referencing providers.

For many renters, the issue is no longer whether they can afford the rent, but whether they can satisfy increasingly stringent underwriting requirements.

What does this mean for landlords?

From a landlord’s perspective, the growing use of guarantors reflects wider changes taking place across the buy-to-let sector.

While rental demand remains exceptionally strong, landlords are becoming more selective as costs rise and regulations continue to become more strict.

Many investors are also now focusing less on simply filling a property quickly and more on reducing potential long-term risks.

Commenting on the trend, a Marco Laurence, Founder at professional rent guarantor service Rentmigo said:

“We’re seeing a big shift in who needs a guarantor. Traditionally, guarantor requests were largely driven by students and younger renters, but today we’re helping an increasing number of working professionals, self-employed people and those moving to the UK for new jobs.

“As landlords face higher costs and stricter regulations, it’s understandable that they’re looking for extra security. Professional guarantor services are increasingly being used to bridge that gap between landlords looking for reassurance and tenants looking for access to housing.”

Could guarantors become the new normal?

Official government data from the English Housing Survey suggests that around 21% of private renters already provided a guarantor when moving into their current home, representing approximately 940,000 households.

However, newer market data suggests that the figure may now be substantially higher.

As rental affordability challenges continue and landlords look at effective risk management, the role of guarantors appears likely to become even bigger.

For landlords, it gives them an additional layer of protection in an increasingly complicated investment environment. For tenants, however, it represents another hurdle to overcome in a rental market that is becoming more financially demanding with each passing year.

How will the sector evolve? We will wait and see.