Budget Wins Praise For Savings And Side Hustles But Business Tax Changes Divide Opinion

coins, currency, investment, insurance, cash, banking, financial, business, money, success, save money concept, save money, savings, stack of money, investment concept, commerce, money background, pen, biro, ballpoint, finance, office, economy, tax, investment, insurance, insurance, insurance, money, money, money, money, money, money background, finance, economy, tax, tax, tax

Measures supporting savers and people earning extra income have attracted praise from financial advisers and business specialists, while changes to tax relief on business sales have emerged as a concern.

Responding through Newspage, eight commentators identified their best and worst decisions from the Autumn Budget. Retaining the £20,000 Cash ISA allowance and increasing the Trading Allowance were among the announcements welcomed, alongside changes to the Lifetime ISA withdrawal penalty.

However, several questioned the balance between support for qualifying high-growth founders and the treatment of established business owners preparing to sell. Housing measures also prompted mixed reactions, with concerns about mortgage affordability, landlord taxation and the potential consequences of a higher bank surcharge.

Lifetime ISA Changes Welcomed, But Bank Surcharge Questioned

Nouran Moustafa, Practice Principal & IFA at Roxton Wealth, said:

“The best decision? Finally fixing the ridiculous Lifetime ISA penalty. Imagine encouraging young people to save for their first home, then penalising them for buying a property that’s slightly too expensive. That never made sense, and I’m delighted it’s being addressed.

“The worst? Increasing the bank surcharge while simultaneously announcing a scheme to help first-time buyers.

“We’re telling banks to support homeownership while increasing their tax burden. Could somebody explain the logic?

“Banks may absorb some of the cost, but they could also adjust mortgage pricing, lending criteria or savings rates.

“It’s rather like encouraging somebody to run a marathon while making their shoes heavier.

“I welcome measures that genuinely help households, but the Chancellor needs to remember that economic policies don’t operate independently.

“The real test isn’t whether individual announcements sound attractive. It’s whether they still make financial sense when you put them all together.”

Business Rates Support Draws Approval

Harry Goodliffe, Director at HTG Mortgages, said:

“The best thing in this Budget is the stuff that didn’t happen. No stamp duty hike for landlords means the rental market didn’t get another whack, and that matters when tenants end up paying for every tax rise aimed at their landlord. The business rates cut was the one decision that made sense, and small high street shops will feel it straight away. The worst bit was everything else for housing. A first home scheme is a nice headline, but it doesn’t make mortgages cheaper or easier to get, and that’s where most buyers are actually stuck. Boring as you like, and not in a good way.”

Business Sale Relief Becomes A Flashpoint

Scott Gallacher, Director at Rowley Turton, said:

“BEST – Cash ISA U-turn

“Retaining the £20,000 Cash ISA allowance is welcome. We’ve already seen clients moving investments into cash for fear of losing flexibility under the original proposals.

“It’s a common-sense U-turn, although I wonder how much time and money has been wasted preparing for a change that never happened.

“WORST – Business Asset Disposal Relief

“Halving Business Asset Disposal Relief to £500,000 while introducing a new Founders’ Relief offering 10% CGT on up to £10 million of gains is almost comical.

“The new relief has such demanding conditions that most successful business owners will never qualify.

“A dentist, accountant or vet who has spent 30 years building a successful business faces a higher tax bill on retirement, while a qualifying high-growth founder could receive vastly more generous relief.

“Both have taken risks, created jobs and built businesses. Why should one be rewarded so much more generously than the other?”

Trading Allowance Increase Offers Help For Side Earners

Harvey Dhillon, Founder & CEO at Zmartly, said:

“The best decision was tripling the Trading Allowance, because it takes small side earnings out of tax and off the tax return. As announced, from 6 April 2027 someone selling on Etsy or eBay after work could take in up to £3,000 a year tax-free. It’s tested on sales, not profit, so anyone with big costs may do better claiming those instead, but for most side hustles it’s a simplification that actually helps. The worst was halving the lifetime limit on Business Asset Disposal Relief to £500,000 from the same date. An owner-manager selling up to retire with lifetime gains above that stands to pay more, with the first bills due on 31 January 2029. The new Founders’ Relief will offer a lower rate on far bigger gains, but as proposed only for companies much larger than most owner-managed firms. That’s what left me scratching my head: ordinary business owners above the new limit pay more while a few big founders pay less.”

Housing Development And Landlord Costs In Focus

Tony Sanchez, Founder at Bridging Loan Directory, said:

“Best: the planned exemption from biodiversity net gain requirements for smaller brownfield housing sites. It addresses a specific cost for developers trying to turn previously used land into homes.

“Worst: another increase in tax on rental income. Landlords are being asked to invest in better properties while keeping less of the income available to pay for improvements. That’s a difficult combination to sell as encouragement.”

Questions Over Which Founders Will Benefit

Matthew Knight, Chief Freelance Officer at Leapers, said:

“HIT: Increasing the trading allowance from £1k to £3k means there’s no unnecessary tax and admin burden for people with a side hustle to help ends meet, or those thinking about starting a business; and the support for self-employed dads, women founders and young entrepreneurs all help to make the UK more entrepreneurial friendly.

“MISS: Making the “Founders Relief” only for certain types of high-growth businesses, when we have a wonderfully diverse group of business owners, many of whom, are likely to fall outside of the benefit, despite doing great things to create value for the country.”

ISA Decision Praised Amid Criticism Of Wider Direction

Samuel Mather-Holgate, Managing Director & IFA at Mather and Murray Financial, said:

“The best decision was leaving ISAs alone. In a country where we desperately need people to save and invest more, tinkering with one of the few savings products people actually understand would have been an extraordinary own goal. Sometimes the smartest thing a Chancellor can do is keep their hands in their pockets.

“The worst decision? The spectacular lack of decisions. This was a vacuum-packed Budget, carefully sealed to preserve absolutely nothing of substance.

“Households need confidence, businesses need certainty and the economy needs growth. Instead, we got the fiscal equivalent of rearranging the cushions while the roof leaks.

“A Budget should be a statement of economic direction, not an elaborate exercise in avoiding difficult choices. The Chancellor appears to have mistaken doing very little for doing no harm. Unfortunately, economic problems don’t disappear just because you refuse to make eye contact with them.”

Business Owners Urged To Review Their Position

Rikesh Bhatt, Founder and Financial Planner at 8 Financial Planning, said:

“The worst decision in this Budget was halving the tax break for selling a business, just as the Chancellor promised a new one for founders.

“From 6 April 2027 the Business Asset Disposal Relief limit falls from £1m to £500k, taxed at 18%. That’s the relief owners of established firms rely on when they sell up and retire.

“The best idea was the proposed Founders’ Relief, a 10% rate on gains of up to £10m. The catch is it’s only a proposal until the consultation closes on 30 November, and the tests look tough for most established firms.

“My message to business owners is simple. Don’t rush a sale on headlines, but get your numbers looked at now so you can decide calmly once the rules are final.”

This article contains general information and commentary only and does not constitute financial or tax advice. Seek advice from a qualified professional before making financial decisions.

Source: Newspage