How practical is the online sales tax idea for retailers?

Written by Kunal Sawhney, CEO, Kalkine

The government had launched a consultation on an online sales tax. Though the duration of the consultation ended on 20 May 2022, it opened a pandora’s box with many coming in support, while others terming it a measure that would have a counter effect on retailers who went ahead and put all their efforts to shift to the modern ways of doing business in retail.

The three-month consultation on changes to business taxes is primarily aimed at rebalancing the taxation of the retail sector among online and in-store retail. As per the consultation, the proposal for an online sales tax (OST) is under the changing business landscape as the pandemic has brought into greater focus longer-term trends that would affect the retail sector. There was a sudden increase in online sales due to pandemic restrictions, and online shopping surged to around 22 per cent in March 2020 from a mere about 3 per cent in 2006. Though, once the restrictions started easing, the online retail sales also witnessed a decline, with people preferring to have experience of in-store retail.

However, the pandemic era necessitated innovation in the retail sector and brought longer-term benefits, which were not only limited to convenience but also included higher productivity and improved choices. Further, the rising popularity of online retail has been continuously putting pressure on high street retail. Hence physical retail outlets started raising concerns about facing an unfair tax and cost burden.

How are businesses being taxed at present?

In Britain, one must pay business rates if he uses a building or part of a building for non-domestic purposes, which includes shops, offices, pubs, warehouses, factories, guest houses, and holiday rental homes. Business rates are worked out based on the rateable value of the non-domestic property. In common practice, it is arrived at by multiplying the rateable value by the correct amount set by the central government, which is also known as a multiplier.

Now, it has become the bone of contention for the brick-and-mortar retail who think that the tax implication is unfair for them, paying a higher level of business rates than their online counterparts, whose business model allows them the advantage of lower commercial rents, resulting in lower rates burdens.

What could come under OST?

The proposal for OST is being considered with a view that it can fund reductions to business rates for physical retail stores, and the government has made it clear that it is not intended to encourage shopping at physical stores over online. Moreover, the consultation has a separate area to explore, the types of transactions where OST can be applied. While the general belief is that it should be imposed on tangible goods, there are views that associated services like delivery and takeaways should also be included in the scope.

Final thoughts

There are an increasing number of brick-and-mortar high street retailers who are supporting the idea of an online sales tax so that it could fund the reduction in business rates for all kinds of retailers and create a level playing field.

Supermarket chains like Sainsbury’s, Tesco, Co-op and Morrisons, Greggs, Waterstones, etc., have been vociferously demanding an increase in taxes on online retailers so that it can be used to fund a reduction in the business rates for physical stores. However, at the same time, there are retailers like Marks & Spencer who think the imposition of OST would lock them down. It would make it difficult to invest in the digital transformation required to survive and grow in the modern, digital era and would punish those who have used their vital resources to shift into modern ways of selling.

At present, business rates raise over £25 billion a year in the UK, which is used to fund vital local services. This consultation is meant to explore the effects of an OST and let the government assess the case for and against implementing such a tax. Now it is on the government to look at innovative and pragmatic ways so that different kinds of retailers are not at a disadvantageous position and continue contributing to the economic growth. Imposing a new tax may not be a good idea at this juncture, albeit a more acceptable to all formula with old taxes could be the way forward.

About Lisa Baker, Editor 3105 Articles
Lisa Baker is the Editor of Always Finance, and writes about Business, Finance Technology and Healthcare. Lisa is also the owner of Need to See IT Publishing.