Protecting financial services in a digital age: the art of sharing 

Written by Wiebe Ruttenberg, Director of Strategy at SecAlliance 

At a time when Russia is waging war in Ukraine and China is threatening Taiwan with a military blockade or even invasion, it is important we also consider the other significant threat posed by Russia and China: the digital threat. 

Russia and China have a long history of carrying out cyber operations towards their alleged adversaries. This includes cyber espionage and attacks aimed at causing obstruction or damage, conducted by their security services or by criminal groups that are supported – or at least tolerated – by the respective governments.  

It also includes acts of cyber theft by organised crime groups. In practice, these threat actors and their motives and interests are not always easy to distinguish from one another. 

Distributed Denial-of-Service (DDoS) attacks that aim to disable banks and other financial entities, or ransomware attacks that encrypt customer data and only release it after ransom payment are all well known to the public.  

In fact, the volume of DDOS attacks targeting European financial firms grew by an astonishing 73% year-on-year by November 2022, according to a recent research report.  

Less well known are cyber-attacks that do not have a direct purpose of obstruction, extortion or theft. These are the cyber-attacks intended to gain a ‘backdoor’ into systems, then just sit there, waiting for the perfect moment to do harm.  

Regardless of the kind of cyber-attack, it is critical that sectors and services essential to a nation’s economy or society are prepared. Consider, for example, what the societal consequences would be of a disruption to the banking system on a national or even a global level? 

Organisations operating in the financial sector should not try to withstand the cyber threat on their own.  

They cannot.  

Firstly, the tactics, techniques and procedures deployed by Russian, Chinese and other Advanced Persistent Threat (APT) actors are often too sophisticated and evolve too fast.  

Secondly, organisations operating in the same sector face the same issues. Re-inventing the wheel is neither efficient nor effective and individual organisations need to team up, help each other and learn from each other. They need to set up and engage in cyber information and intelligence sharing. 

Unfortunately, current cyber information and intelligence sharing partnerships, where they do exist, all too often remain stuck at the tactical level, exchanging just technical feeds. 

They fail to involve anyone other than technical experts and they fail to establish real trust.  

Cyber resilience is about the continuity of an organisation, so there must be involvement at the executive level. It is essential to understand that there is no learning without real sharing. So CISOs and their staff need to be backed by their executive leadership when sharing their organisation’s dirty secrets, worst nightmares and lessons learned with their peers. 

Back in 2020, the Euro Cyber Resilience Board – chaired by the European Central Bank – led by example and launched a Cyber Information and Intelligence Sharing Initiative for pan-European Financial Market Infrastructures (CIISI-EU). The Central Bank of Ireland followed swiftly by setting up CIISI-IE for the Irish financial sector. 

With these two successful examples in mind, the EU’s recently entered into force Digital Operational Resilience Act (DORA) is addressing this issue, calling for financial entities to set-up information sharing arrangements.  

However, the establishment of trust among participants is critical to a successful sharing community.  

In practice, sharing organisations are often competitors and cannot reach the minimum level of trust required. In addition, trust is not about compliance and its establishment cannot be enforced by supervisory rules and regulations.  

At European and national level, the above-mentioned examples in the financial sector have shown that a gentle push by the relevant authorities (e.g., the European Central Bank and the Central Bank of Ireland respectively) and involving an impartial third-party moderator help establish trust and get meaningful information sharing going.  

In a world characterised by a serious shortage of cyber security experts, expertise and resources need to be allocated in a very focussed manner and commonly shared as far as possible. For the sake of financial stability, it is time to get serious about sharing. 

About Lisa Baker, Editor 3105 Articles
Lisa Baker is the Editor of Always Finance, and writes about Business, Finance Technology and Healthcare. Lisa is also the owner of Need to See IT Publishing.