Draft Finance Bill 2025–26 Targets Tax Evasion Through Umbrella Companies – APSCo Highlights Financial Risk to Recruiters

The UK government’s newly published Draft Finance Bill 2025–26 has introduced significant proposals aimed at clamping down on tax fraud and non-compliance within labour supply chains—placing a new financial burden on recruitment firms. Under draft legislation due to come into effect from April 2026, staffing firms could be held jointly and severally liable for unpaid PAYE tax if they use non-compliant umbrella companies.

This move signals a tougher stance by HMRC to address abuses in the temporary labour market, where umbrella companies have been linked to tax avoidance schemes and so-called “phoenix” company fraud—where firms dissolve and re-form to avoid liabilities.

The Association of Professional Staffing Companies (APSCo), which represents professional recruitment firms, has responded with caution. Tania Bowers, Global Public Policy Director at APSCo, said the changes will have considerable financial and operational implications:

“The details published in yesterday’s Finance Bill were generally as expected. HMRC has clearly set its sights on preventing tax non-compliance, and fraud via umbrella companies are at the centre of its focus. HMRC has published draft legislation that will be introduced in April 2026 which puts the onus on recruitment firms through joint and several liability for PAYE taxes.

For recruitment firms, now is the time to prepare for the changes before they come into effect. During the consultation period, a few APSCo members expressed significant concerns around the legal implications, but there was a recognition that the legislation would create additional administrative burdens for recruiters that engage umbrella companies.

In particular, there are concerns as to the level of transparency that will be needed to protect recruitment firms. The guidance soon to be published by HMRC must outline not only its own approach, but also clear information to help staffing companies implement best practice strategies. The details published so far don’t provide recruiters with the additional tools to manage the new requirements; they simply put the responsibility on staffing firms to know the details of their umbrella supply chain, or face financial penalties.

There are some measures that will help recruiters and umbrella companies, including the specification around the transition phases for directors and the prevention of ‘Phoenixism’. However, more is needed. As APSCo has previously highlighted, licensing of the umbrella market and statutory codes of practice are needed to prevent fraud and equip those that are being tasked with tackling the issue with the appropriate resources to do so.

The digitalisation of services that has been touted as a means of helping small businesses interact with HMRC is welcome news, though the implementation of this will be no easy task. This needs to be made readily available as soon as possible in order to help staffing firms prepare ahead of the changes to legislation.

APSCo will continue to leverage its close relationship with HMRC to guide and inform members on the changes during the preparation period ahead of the April implementation.”

From a financial perspective, the proposed changes raise serious questions about risk exposure and compliance costs for recruitment firms. Without a statutory licensing regime for umbrella companies, many in the industry feel the reforms shift liability without providing adequate enforcement tools or support for due diligence.

The draft bill also includes anti-avoidance measures to prevent the use of new corporate structures to escape tax debts, along with transitional provisions for directors. These are seen as positive steps but, according to APSCo, fall short of a holistic solution.

For finance directors, auditors and risk officers across the recruitment and staffing sector, the message is clear: now is the time to audit your supply chains, assess contractual liabilities, and invest in robust compliance frameworks. The cost of inaction could be significant—not only in potential tax liabilities but also in reputational damage and operational disruption.

Further HMRC guidance is expected in the coming months. In the meantime, APSCo continues to push for greater regulatory clarity, improved transparency in the umbrella sector, and targeted support to help recruiters prepare for the financial implications of the legislation.

About Lisa Baker, Editor 3105 Articles
Lisa Baker is the Editor of Always Finance, and writes about Business, Finance Technology and Healthcare. Lisa is also the owner of Need to See IT Publishing.