Black Friday shoppers warned that BNPL purchases could ruin their mortgage prospects next year even if every instalment is paid on time

A person holding a small house in their hand
As Black Friday returns with its usual avalanche of discounts, one mortgage expert is warning that the biggest financial risk for first time buyers is not the price of the gifts, but the way they choose to pay for them.
With nearly every major retailer pushing buy now pay later options at checkout, shoppers are slipping into credit agreements far more easily than they realise, and the consequences could reach far beyond Christmas.
Joseph Lane, a mortgage broker at Mortgage Lane, says BNPL has quietly become a major stumbling block for people trying to get onto the property ladder.
“Lenders are now paying much closer attention to instalment spending, and even small festive purchases can snowball into a pattern that may later alarm underwriters reviewing an applicant’s finances,” said Lane.
Lane says shoppers underestimate BNPL because it feels informal compared with traditional credit. He says,
“People see BNPL as this friendly little buffer that helps with seasonal spending, but to a lender it is still debt. Whether it is interest free or not, it tells a story about how you manage money, and banks pay attention to that.”
He adds that the heavy promotion of BNPL during Christmas creates a perfect storm. “Retailers make BNPL look effortless. The button pops up everywhere you shop, and you barely think about the fact you’re agreeing to spread payments.
“When someone repeats that behaviour across multiple purchases, they end up with a stack of instalments that linger for months. Lenders don’t love seeing that.”
Lane explains that the average festive present may cost “somewhere between forty and seventy pounds,” but the danger is volume rather than price. “Most people are buying for five, six or more loved ones. That’s where things escalate.
“What feels like a little ‘pay later’ cushion can suddenly turn into hundreds of pounds that still have to be cleared by the time you apply for a mortgage.”
He says many shoppers wrongly assume that because BNPL instalments are short term, they will be irrelevant by next year. “That’s not how lenders look at it. Mortgage underwriters routinely examine three to six months of bank statements.
“If your statements are full of BNPL payments, it raises questions. It doesn’t matter that the initial purchase was months ago. What matters is the pattern.”

BNPL’s hidden impact on mortgage approval

Lane says missed payments are the most obvious risk but not the only one.
“If someone slips up even once, that late payment could hit their credit file. People don’t realise how unforgiving some BNPL platforms are with reporting missed instalments. Even a small blip can lower your score at the wrong moment.”
He says that the biggest problem is how BNPL affects affordability calculations. “Banks want to know what you can genuinely afford each month. Every BNPL instalment chips away at the disposable income that lenders use in their assessments. When they run the numbers, those instalments can be the difference between approval and rejection.”
Lane also says lenders are increasingly wary of people who rely on BNPL for non-essential purchases.
“If your statements show repeated BNPL use for day-to-day spending, a lender will wonder why. They will ask whether you can realistically handle a mortgage if you already need instalments for normal shopping.”
He notes that BNPL reporting is inconsistent across the credit industry, which often leads lenders to dig deeper. “Some BNPL firms report everything, others report nothing, and others fall somewhere in between.
“Because of that inconsistency, lenders assume there may be more instalment spending than what appears on the credit file. It is not a great position to be in as an applicant.”
Lane adds that the BNPL sector is “growing at a pace that lenders cannot ignore.”
He says,
“Over the next couple of years, BNPL spending is expected to rise sharply. Banks are responding by tightening their checks. We’re already seeing more detailed questions in underwriting about instalment payments and digital credit platforms.”

Additional risks many first time buyers overlook

Lane says frequent BNPL use leaves another, less obvious trail.
“Every time you set up a BNPL plan, there is usually a soft check. People think soft checks don’t matter, and yes, they don’t lower your score, but lenders can still see them. A long list of credit searches can make you look financially unsettled.”
He also explains that BNPL can indirectly weaken your savings record.
“Lenders love savings discipline. It helps them trust that you can manage long term commitments. If you’re juggling instalments every month, it becomes harder to save consistently. For first time buyers, that lost momentum counts.”
Lane warns that BNPL can also create what lenders call “financial friction”. “If someone constantly shifts money around to cover instalments, uses different BNPL providers, or pays on the final reminder every time, lenders see that as messy money management. It is subtle, but it matters.”

Advice for buyers hoping to purchase a home soon

Lane urges anyone planning to buy a home within the next 18 months to be extremely cautious during the Black Friday period.
“My advice is simple. If you can pay for something upfront, do it. If you can’t, it might be a sign that the purchase can wait.”
He says people often feel embarrassed about cutting back during the holidays, but they shouldn’t be.
“Your friends and family won’t think less of you if you skip one or two gifts while saving for a home. What will matter far more is whether you get that mortgage offer next year.”