Auditors and finance teams urged to strengthen controls as fake invoice scams persist

Auditors and finance teams are being encouraged to tighten oversight and reinforce internal controls as increasingly sophisticated fake invoice scams continue to target organisations.

Vipul Sheth, Chartered Accountant, auditor and MD of accountancy outsourcing specialists Advancetrack, warned that one of the most common red flags is an invoice arriving unexpectedly.

“One of the biggest red flags is an invoice arriving unexpectedly, particularly if it claims to be from a supplier or service you don’t immediately recognise. It’s vital to be aware that many fraudsters attempt to spoof legitimate companies, so businesses should be especially cautious if invoices arrive via accounting platforms or from email addresses that look slightly different to those previously used. Other warning signs include incorrect currency, unusual formatting, or invoices that don’t clearly relate to work that has actually been carried out.”

He also stressed the importance of scrutinising payment information carefully.

“Pay close attention to the bank details listed on the invoice and ensure there is a clear security process in place for any requested changes. This should include independently verifying changes, for example by confirming with them over the phone using trusted contact details.”

If an invoice appears suspicious, Sheth advised against acting immediately or engaging with potentially fraudulent correspondence.

“Take a beat, and don’t act on the invoice straight away. It’s important not to reply directly to the email or click any links or attachments. Instead, contact the organisation the invoice claims to be from using known, trusted contact details – such as a phone number or email address you already have on file.

“If anything doesn’t add up, escalate it internally and involve IT or cyber specialists to assess whether any systems or data may have been compromised.”

Where a fraudulent invoice is uncovered during an audit, Sheth said it should be escalated without delay and treated as a serious control issue.

“If a fake invoice is identified during an audit, it should be flagged to the organisation immediately so it can be reviewed without delay. While audits are typically retrospective, uncovering a fraudulent invoice is a serious red flag and should prompt swift action from management, including securing relevant documentation and assessing how the invoice was processed in the first place.

“In many cases, this should also trigger a wider review to determine whether the issue is isolated or indicative of a more systematic control failure. That might involve reviewing similar transactions, supplier records or approval processes to identify any broader weaknesses. Having that level of oversight is critical, not only to understand the true level of risk, but to ensure appropriate controls are put in place to prevent a recurrence.”

Sheth said strong preventative controls are essential when it comes to reducing the risk of invoice fraud, adding:

“Strong preventative controls are essential when it comes to reducing the risk of invoice fraud. Invoices should always be cross-checked against known suppliers and verified work, with particular care taken around unexpected requests or changes to payment details. Businesses should be especially wary of invoices received via unfamiliar email addresses or platforms, or where details such as currency, company address or bank information don’t match what’s previously been used.

“Any request to change bank details should be independently verified using trusted contact information, such as calling the supplier directly rather than replying to an email. Clear internal escalation procedures, regular staff awareness training and close collaboration between finance and IT teams can all help organisations spot potential fraud earlier and prevent costly mistakes.”