Written by James Cordiner, Tax Consultancy Manager at Markel Tax – a specialist business insurer and tax advisory company.
An HMRC investigation can place significant pressure on an organisation, whether it’s a limited company, sole trader or partnership. Even when its tax affairs are accurate, responding to questions, retrieving records and working with accountants takes unwelcome extra time and money.
HMRC carries out compliance checks to confirm that businesses have paid the right amount of tax, claimed the correct allowances and followed the relevant tax rules. A check may involve requests for information, meetings with company representatives or visits to business premises. HMRC may also examine financial records, assets and the way the business operates.
No business can completely remove the possibility of an investigation but the following five steps can help reduce the risk of problems and put the company in a stronger position if HMRC makes contact.
- Keep complete and accurate records
Good record keeping is the foundation of tax compliance.
Limited companies must retain records about the company itself, alongside adequate financial and accounting information in accordance with the Companies Act 2006. These records should explain the figures reported in the company’s accounts and tax returns. HMRC may review them as part of a compliance check.
Records should be accurate, accessible and supported by evidence. This may include invoices, receipts, contracts, bank statements, payroll information and details of business expenses.
Responsibility should be assigned to specific people within the company. Regular checks can then identify missing documents, inconsistent entries or unexplained transactions before they become more serious concerns.
- Submit accurate returns on time
Late, incomplete or inconsistent filings can attract attention and create avoidable questions.
Businesses should maintain a clear calendar covering Corporation Tax, VAT, PAYE and other relevant obligations. Figures should be checked against accounting records before anything is submitted.
Particular care is needed when a company has experienced significant change. Rapid growth, restructuring, new income streams or changes to employment arrangements can affect its tax position. Professional advice should be sought before filing where the treatment of a transaction is uncertain.
Even when an accountant prepares the return, responsibility remains with the taxpayer. HMRC advises businesses to choose tax agents carefully, particularly where their affairs are complex.
- Review areas of tax risk regularly
A tax review can reveal weaknesses before HMRC does.
The review should consider whether the company’s approach remains appropriate as the business changes. Common areas requiring close attention include employment status, director remuneration, business expenses, VAT treatment and the use of subcontractors.
The business should document the reasons behind important tax decisions. Where external advice has been taken, keep a copy of that advice with the relevant records. This creates a clear trail showing how the company reached its position.
Concerns should be addressed promptly. Leaving an issue unresolved can increase the work required later and may lead to additional tax, interest or penalties imposed by HMRC.
- Put fee protection insurance in place
Professional support can be invaluable during an HMRC investigation. Typically, this will involve a significant amount of extra time from the company’s accountant but, in some cases, may also involve specialist tax advice. Added up together, it can create an unwelcome bill.
A detailed check may require an accountant or tax adviser to review records, prepare correspondence, attend meetings and respond to further questions. HMRC allows businesses to appoint an agent to manage their tax affairs and deal with compliance checks on their behalf.
Fee protection insurance can cover eligible professional fees arising from an HMRC investigation, subject to the policy’s terms, conditions and exclusions. This can give a business access to specialist support without facing an unexpected advisory bill.
Cover should be arranged before an investigation begins. Businesses should review the scope of protection carefully, including the taxes, enquiries and professional costs covered.
- Respond quickly and professionally
An HMRC letter should never be ignored.
The business should confirm what information has been requested, note every deadline and inform its accountant or tax adviser immediately. HMRC may issue penalties where a company fails to provide information required by an inspection or information notice without a reasonable excuse.
Responses should be clear, factual and limited to the question asked. Avoid speculation or sending incomplete information without explanation. Keep copies of all correspondence and keep an accurate, contemporaneous record of any conversations with HMRC.
A calm, organised response can help the investigation progress efficiently. It also allows the company’s management team to stay focused on running the business.
Preparation makes the difference. Strong records, accurate reporting, regular reviews, suitable insurance and early professional support can help a company face an HMRC investigation with confidence.
James Cordiner is Tax Consultancy Manager at Markel Tax – a specialist business insurer and tax advisory company.
James is a former Inspector of Taxes who worked in HMRC for more than 17 years in a variety of roles. He joined Markel Tax in 2005 as a Senior Tax Consultant and has extensive knowledge of tax investigations and the Alternative Dispute Resolution process having been involved with this since its inception as a pilot scheme.