Why shopping around for a remortgage can backfire when your credit file is not clean

man holding model house at desk with calculator

Ask anyone what to do when a mortgage deal ends and the answer is always the same: shop around. For most borrowers that is sound advice, repeated so often it has stopped being examined. If your credit file has defaults, missed payments or a CCJ on it, it deserves examining, because the route that looks cheaper on a comparison table is also the one most likely to end in a decline.

The timing makes it worth getting right. Bank Rate has been held at 3.75% for a fifth consecutive meeting, with the next decision due on 17 September. Average standard variable rates sit around 7.13% against an average two-year fixed rate of about 5.6%, on Moneyfacts figures for early August. Those are averages of advertised rates rather than quotes, but the gap is why lapsing onto a standard rate is so expensive. What the standard advice leaves out is that a failed application carries a cost of its own.

Specialist brokers make this point often. A Little Mortgage Advice, a firm that deals mainly with adverse credit cases, is one of the few I have seen spell out the trade-off properly: for a borrower with recent credit problems, the real decision is not which new lender to pick, it is whether to leave the current one at all. Three things decide that, and none of them is the headline rate.

The two routes are not judged the same way

A product transfer means taking a new rate from your existing lender. A remortgage means moving to a new one, and regulation treats the two very differently. Under the FCA’s rules, the full affordability assessment does not apply where a borrower replaces an existing mortgage with a new deal from the same lender, borrows no more than is already outstanding apart from fees, and nothing material changes. The provision is MCOB 11.6.3R. A new lender has no equivalent carve-out and must assess the application from scratch.

The rules say nothing about credit searches. Whether a lender runs one on a transfer is its own policy rather than a requirement. Several large lenders publish that they do not credit check or ask for proof of income on a like-for-like transfer; others do. What matters most in either case is conduct on the mortgage itself, and missed mortgage payments can see even a transfer refused.

  Product transfer Remortgage
Affordability assessment Not required on a like-for-like deal (MCOB 11.6.3R) Full assessment, income and outgoings
Credit check Lender’s own policy; several large lenders run none Hard search in almost all cases
Payment history Already held by the lender Reviewed as part of underwriting
Extra borrowing Not usually possible Possible, subject to assessment
Fees Often none Product, valuation and legal fees may apply

 

A lower rate is not the same as a lower cost

Total cost decides this, not the advertised rate, and the arithmetic is closer than most borrowers expect. Take a £180,000 balance, with the existing lender offering 5.10% and no fee against a new lender at 4.85% with a £999 product fee. The rate gap is worth roughly £450 a year in interest, so around £900 over a two-year deal, against that £999 fee.

  Existing lender New lender
Two-year fixed rate 5.10% 4.85%
Product fee £0 £999
Interest saved over two years – About £900
Net position after fee – Roughly £100 worse off

 

The figures are illustrative, but the shape of them is what gets missed. The cheaper rate leaves the borrower marginally worse off before any valuation fee, any legal cost, or the chance of being declined and ending up on the standard variable rate while the clock runs down.

Scattergun applications do lasting damage

The instinct when an application looks uncertain is to try several lenders and see who says yes. It is the most damaging thing a borrower can do in the weeks before a deal expires. Every full application leaves a hard search on the file, visible for up to two years, and a cluster of them close together reads to an underwriter as somebody in difficulty looking for anyone who will have them. That impression harms a case more than the score itself does. Checking your own report, by contrast, leaves no mark at all, and it is the obvious first step.

When moving lender is still the right call

None of this means staying put is always correct. The case for a transfer weakens as a file recovers. Once a problem is three or more years old and settled, and mortgage payments have been maintained throughout, the pool of lenders willing to look grows considerably. A lower loan-to-value band offsets history in much the same way. And because a transfer cannot usually raise extra borrowing, anyone who needs to release funds has little choice but to look at the wider market.

The criteria differ enough between lenders to be worth reading properly before applying anywhere. The same firm’s guide to remortgaging with bad credit sets out how lenders assess each route and where the cut-offs tend to fall, and it is more candid than most about who should not bother applying.

Start earlier than feels necessary

Three to six months before a deal ends leaves time to correct errors on a credit file, which is more common a fix than people assume, and to test the wider market while a product transfer remains a fallback. Leaving it to the final weeks removes that option, and the fallback is the whole point. The question for a borrower with a patchy file is not which lender offers the lowest rate. It is whether moving at all is worth the risk of being told no. Get that wrong and the cheaper rate never materialises.