Artificial intelligence is emerging as a new competitive challenge for Britain’s commercial insurance brokers, as customers increasingly gain new ways to research cover and obtain indicative prices before speaking to an adviser.
New research from GlobalData suggests commercial brokers are already beginning to view AI as a meaningful competitor despite the technology remaining at a relatively early stage as an insurance distribution channel.
GlobalData’s 2026 UK Commercial Broker Survey found that 9.2% of brokers identified AI as the biggest threat to their business.
That puts AI behind only competition from other brokers and challenging soft-market conditions among the threats identified by respondents. Significantly, AI now ranks ahead of competition from established price comparison websites.
AI Could Change Where The Insurance Journey Begins
The concern is not necessarily that AI will replace commercial insurance brokers outright.
Instead, conversational AI has the potential to change the point at which customers first interact with insurers, aggregators and brokers.
Consumers and businesses have traditionally used search engines, price comparison websites, insurer websites or brokers themselves when beginning their search for insurance.
AI platforms potentially add another route, allowing users to ask questions about appropriate types of cover, compare options and, where supported by connected services, obtain indicative pricing.
Sahil Haider, Insurance Analyst at GlobalData, said:
“AI is still at a relatively early stage as an insurance distribution channel, yet brokers already view it as a meaningful competitive threat. The fact that AI ranks ahead of established channels such as price comparison websites as a threat, highlights the potential for conversational platforms to reshape how customers begin their insurance purchasing journey.”
Insurers And Aggregators Move Into Conversational AI
The development comes as insurance businesses and comparison services explore ways of establishing a presence within ChatGPT and other conversational platforms.
According to GlobalData, ManyPets recently launched a ChatGPT plugin, following similar moves from MoneySuperMarket and Simply Business earlier in 2026.
Such integrations can potentially enable customers to obtain indicative prices or other product information through an AI conversation before being redirected to a provider’s own website.
For commercial brokers, the trend could prove particularly significant when dealing with relatively straightforward insurance requirements from small and medium-sized businesses.
Simply Business, for example, has launched a ChatGPT app designed to allow SME customers to obtain guide pricing for commercial insurance through the platform.
Haider said:
“For straightforward commercial insurance needs, conversational AI could increasingly influence the initial research and comparison stage. This creates a risk for brokers if customers are directed towards insurers or aggregators before considering broker advice.”
Could AI Replace Commercial Insurance Brokers?
The research does not suggest that the traditional commercial insurance broker is about to disappear.
More complicated business risks frequently require detailed assessment of a company’s circumstances, specialist market knowledge and support in placing appropriate cover.
Commercial insurance can also involve considerably more complexity than simply finding the cheapest premium.
Businesses may need assistance understanding exclusions, policy limits and risk exposures, while brokers can play an important role when unusual or specialist risks need to be placed with insurers.
This leaves human brokers with an opportunity to distinguish themselves through expertise and advice rather than attempting to compete solely on speed or price.
However, the way customers discover those brokers could change substantially.
If more businesses begin their insurance searches by asking an AI assistant what cover they need, brokers may increasingly need to consider how their services and expertise are represented within AI-driven discovery channels as well as conventional search engines.
Digital Visibility Could Become Increasingly Important
The shift could create a similar challenge to that previously posed by search engines and price comparison websites.
Brokers that historically relied heavily on referrals or traditional online search may need to think more broadly about digital distribution as conversational platforms become another potential gateway to financial products.
Haider concluded:
“As AI becomes more embedded in insurance product discovery, brokers will need to ensure they remain visible wherever customers begin their purchasing journey. Those that adapt their digital distribution strategies while clearly demonstrating the value of human advice will be better positioned to maintain customer relationships as AI-enabled insurance distribution develops.”
For the commercial broking sector, the findings suggest AI’s immediate impact may therefore be less about replacing advisers and more about controlling the first stage of the customer journey.
A business that previously began its search by contacting a broker could increasingly start by asking an AI platform about the types of insurance it requires, expected costs and available providers.
That potentially gives insurers, aggregators and technology platforms an opportunity to establish a relationship with the customer before a traditional broker enters the process.
For brokers, maintaining visibility while demonstrating the value of specialist human advice could consequently become an increasingly important part of competing in an AI-driven insurance market.
About The Research
GlobalData’s 2026 UK Commercial Insurance Broker Survey was conducted during January and February 2026 and surveyed 250 brokers.
Prior to 2025, the questions were asked through FWD’s Broking Now Omnibus telephone panel.