The public sector and PLCs may seem worlds apart in the way they operate – but an award-winning Welsh council’s procurement function could prove a valuable learning opportunity for those in the entrepreneurial world.
By pursuing a people-first approach to transformation and carefully maintaining and enhancing this approach over the past quarter of a century, Caerphilly County Borough Council has recognised that it is the staff they employ not the technology they deploy which are the essential element of success.
The challenges of modern procurement
Much like the public sector, UK PLCs face continuing challenges around talent shortages, supplier risk and Government-mandated demands for transparency. With these procurement functions now business-as-usual, they’re also expected to deliver cost savings, satisfy ESG obligations and ensure resilient, auditable systems are embedded in operations.
Complicated as this may be, the team at Caerphilly – which picked up three Wales GO Awards in recognition of their success – has achieved what many businesses are still grappling with.
The public sector faces increased obligations under the Procurement Act 2023, which obliges them to ensure ‘clear and transparent commercial pipelines and a good understanding of the market to plan for procurement process’.
Simultaneously, procurement leaders face a talent challenge, according to the Chartered Institute of Procurement & Supply Salary Guide. It reports 58% of employers globally are struggling to find and retain procurement talent. For many organisations, the answer to this problem is to buy new technology; the council took another path and opted for a combined technology and people-focused approach.
Gowing demands and unsuitable legacy systems
Caerphilly’s local authority serves around 175,000 residents and manages a diverse supplier ecosystem spanning construction, social care, facilities management and IT infrastructure. Its situation will be familiar to many organisations: it faced budgetary pressures, increasing compliance requirements, and a pressing need to modernise legacy procurement processes.
For years, it depended on cumbersome manual and spreadsheet-based processes. This inefficiency served only to exacerbate existing skills shortages, an issue acknowledged by more than 70% of respondents to Deloitte’s Global Chief Procurement Officer survey. These legacy processes also made it difficult to ensure the effective supplier scrutiny demanded from public sector bodies.
A radical break with tradition
The council made a radical decision: start with the people and build procurement as a strategic function. Procurement Director Liz Lucas decided not to focus on qualifications, choosing instead to look for people who were curious, adaptable and exhibited valuable problem-solving skills. This involved recruitment from non-traditional backgrounds, building multi-disciplinary teams, and creating dedicated Supplier Liaison Officers to manage supplier relationships post contract award. Whereas many businesses see supplier management as an afterthought, Caerphilly formalised it, ensuring it became a strategic enabler, not just an administrative function.
Technology also played a critical role, not least because of the valuable data it generated. Shifting from spreadsheets to real-time procurement analytics and developing an ‘obligation matrix’ to track supplier commitments and performance significantly improved processes. It also helped reduce contract review timelines from days or hours of work, down to under an hour. None of this would have been possible without the automation the technology delivers, but the real value came from transforming procurement from reactive reporting to proactive decision-making.
Challenging accepted practice to make a difference
Challenging accepted practice became the norm at Caerphilly. The team piloted new structures, invested in technology before benefits were fully proven, and saw experimentation as just one element of the overall improvement process. Their approach centred around people who wanted to make a difference; technology that enabled rather than constrained; and the leadership doing things differently.
A worthwhile lesson wider industry players can take from their experience is that technology is not the biggest challenge – hiring and retaining the right people is. Perhaps the most profound takeaway is that people with curiosity and learning agility may be more important than those with traditional credentials alone.
Caerphilly’s foresight in appointing Supplier Liaison Officers should be seen as a template for private-sector organisations to follow. Rather than thinking procurement ends with the purchasing decision and ensure ongoing, effective supplier management and communication remains in place throughout the contract lifecycle – and can therefore transform supplier performance as well as building internal credibility.
A marathon, not a sprint
It’s also important to acknowledge that the council didn’t just throw money at automation technologies – it spent more than two decades building the data foundations advanced automation solutions need. It’s proved very effective and reflects a broader trend of leading enterprise procurement functions removing low-value administrative tasks so people can focus on strategic decisions. As a recent KPMG study stated: “procurement teams must focus on people and processes – ensuring their digital transformation strategy includes change management, training and a modular approach that evolves with business needs.”
The procurement landscape is full to the brim with stories about AI, analytics and the promise of digital platforms. Caerphilly’s experience suggests one of the more enduring lessons is much simpler: technology enables change, but it’s people that drive it and make it successful. UK businesses seeking to modernise procurement would be advised to examine their award-winning model. It clearly demonstrates how sustainable transformation works best when leadership, talent and technology evolve in harmony.
—
– Ilija Ugrinic, Senior Vice President, Strategy & Marketing at Proactis